Sikh Truckers Fight US Rule That Could Sideline Thousands Over English
The Federal Motor Carrier Safety Administration (FMCSA) has received over 2,200 public comments on its proposed English Language Proficiency (ELP) rule, with most supporting stricter enforcement. However, the Sikh Coalition has emerged as a prominent critic, warning that the measure could lead to discrimination against minority drivers.
The Sikh Coalition, a nonprofit organization focused on protecting the civil rights of Sikh Americans, submitted comments opposing the rule. While acknowledging the safety rationale behind requiring English proficiency for commercial drivers, the group argued that the proposal lacks clear guidelines for roadside inspectors to assess language skills fairly.
Sikh Coalition raises concerns over potential bias
The organization, which provides legal services and advocates for Sikh truck drivers, emphasized the risk of discriminatory enforcement. In its filing, the Coalition stated that without proper safeguards, the rule could be used to target drivers based on appearance or accent rather than actual language ability.
The FMCSA’s Notice of Proposed Rulemaking (NPRM) seeks to formalize existing regulations by placing drivers out of service for ELP violations. The only exception would apply to truck traffic operating exclusively near the U.S.-Mexico border without venturing further inland.
The majority of comments supporting the rule came from an organized email campaign referencing Dalilah Coleman, a five-year-old injured in a 2024 California crash involving a driver who was in the country illegally. The campaign’s messages argued that stricter language requirements could prevent similar incidents.
Proposed rule and industry response
Meanwhile, legislation known as Dalilah’s Law, which includes ELP provisions, has stalled in Congress. Though it advanced in the House Transportation Committee, the bill has not been taken up by the full House, and its Senate counterpart failed to progress in committee. With the current legislative session nearing its end, the bill is unlikely to pass this year.
The FMCSA will now review all submitted comments before deciding whether to finalize the rule. The agency’s decision could have significant implications for how language proficiency is enforced in the trucking industry, particularly for minority drivers who may face heightened scrutiny.
Sign up free to ask CAMAL AI for a summary, the key points or anything else about this story.
Related stories
CAMAL AI
Financial Ports Newsletter
The maritime economy, every morning
Ports, shipping and freight markets in one short email. Free.
