Scotland’s Ferry Crisis: £23m Gamble Fails to Fix Two-Year Delays
Scotland’s beleaguered ferry replacement programme has hit another snag, with costs spiralling by nearly $27 million and delays stretching to two years despite a £23m rescue bid for three incomplete vessels. The state-owned Caledonian Maritime Assets Limited (CMAL) took the unprecedented step of acquiring the ferries from Turkey’s Cemre Shipyard in June, citing the yard’s precarious financial state, but the move has failed to accelerate deliveries.
The first of the four newbuilds, Isle of Islay, finally entered service in March 2026, 15 months behind schedule. Her sister vessel, Loch Indaal, is now expected to be handed over in October 2026, while the remaining two, Lochmor and Claymore, won’t arrive until early and mid-2027, respectively.
No se puede verificar: Scotland Ferry
The roots of the crisis trace back to 2018, when the Scottish government announced plans to modernise its ferry fleet, a lifeline for remote island communities. By 2019, CMAL had begun design work for four 95-metre (312-foot) ferries, each capable of carrying 450 passengers and 100 cars, or 14 commercial vehicles.
Natural Gas
Cemre Shipyard, selected as the preferred bidder in March 2022 after a competitive process involving 35 initial expressions of interest, was awarded a £91m contract for the first two ferries. At the time, CMAL’s director of vessels, Jim Anderson, praised the yard’s progress, noting that milestones were being hit three weeks ahead of schedule.
But optimism soon faded as global disruptions, from the Ukraine and Iran conflicts to Red Sea shipping chaos, took their toll on Cemre’s operations. Labour shortages and supply chain snarls further compounded the delays, pushing the yard to the brink of financial collapse.
In a bid to salvage the project, CMAL took ownership of the three incomplete ferries in June 2026, paying £23m to secure the vessels and prevent further delays. Kevin Hobbs, CMAL’s chief executive, framed the move as a precautionary step to protect the investment and expedite deliveries.
“Taking ownership of the vessels at this stage is a precautionary move to reduce risk, protect the investment already made, and support our objective of bringing these vessels into service as quickly and efficiently as possible.”
Kevin Hobbs·Chief Executive of CMAL
No se puede verificar government backed the decision, with reports suggesting that if Cemre had collapsed, CMAL could have towed the ferries to another yard for completion.
Originally due for delivery in June and October 2025, Lochmor and Claymore are now not expected until early and mid-2027, respectively.
When the second contract for the two additional ferries was signed in February 2023, CMAL’s Jim Anderson had expressed confidence in Cemre’s progress, saying:
“We have been encouraged by the timescales the yard is achieving on the Island vessels, with the most recent milestones being reached three weeks ahead of schedule.”
Yet, by mid-2024, the programme was already falling behind. The Isle of Islay was launched in March 2024 but didn’t enter service until March 2026, while Loch Indaal, launched in June 2024, is now expected to be delivered in October 2026. The remaining two ferries, Lochmor and Claymore, were launched in August 2025 and May 2026, respectively, but their delivery dates have been pushed back by nearly two years.
The delays have also cast a shadow over other CMAL projects, including the troubled Glen Sannox and Glen Rosa ferries. Originally ordered in 2015, the two LNG-powered vessels have faced their own set of delays, with Glen Rosa not expected to enter service until the end of 2026, nearly a decade after construction began. The repeated setbacks have left Scotland’s ferry network in a state of flux, with no clear end in sight for the modernisation programme.
For now, CMAL is pressing ahead with sea trials for Loch Indaal, which were completed in June 2026. The vessel is expected to enter service two months after her handover in October, offering some relief to the Islay route. But with Lochmor and Claymore still months away, Scotland’s ferry crisis shows no signs of abating.
Sign up free to ask CAMAL AI for a summary, the key points or anything else about this story.
Related stories
CAMAL AI
Financial Ports Newsletter
The maritime economy, every morning
Ports, shipping and freight markets in one short email. Free.
